Herring Cottage, 9 Carrs Yard, Bagdale, Whitby, YO21 1QR

HP Score
- Verdict: INVESTIGATE, on a scale of Buy, Investigate, Avoid.
Mixed signals - investigate
Verdict
Derived from HomePortfolio scores
Herring Cottage earns an INVESTIGATE rating with HP Score 56/100. Investment score 53/100 reflects moderate fundamentals. Crime intensity is elevated. Walkability is excellent (89/100). Flood risk is not assessed: check the Environment Agency long-term flood map before offering. Tenure is freehold. Every figure here comes from the live HomePortfolio API; anything it does not publish is left out.
Valuation & Market
Risk Overview
- Flood RiskUnknown
- SubsidenceModerate
- RadonLow
- MiningUnknown
- LandslideSignificant
- Air QualityLow
- NoiseLow
Planning Activity
- Pending26/05909/LBChange of use from retail (class E) and dwelling (class C3) on the ground floor to cafe and retail (class E) with single dwelling to the upper floors. Works to include internal alterations to secure the structural stability of the building, including removal of a 1980s staircase and external works to windows, render, an external staircase to access the first floor and an outside w.c.
- Pending26/05908/FULChange of use from retail (class E) and dwelling (class C3) on the ground floor to cafe and retail (class E) with single dwelling to the upper floors. Works to include internal alterations to secure the structural stability of the building, including removal of a 1980s staircase and external works to windows, render, an external staircase to access the first floor and an outside w.c.
- Pending26/05842/ADVInternal digital tv screen
Ownership
- Corporate Ownership69.3%
- Overseas OwnershipNo
- Lease Term Remaining-
- CovenantsRestrictive
- Lease TypeFreehold
- Last Ownership Change2021-08-24
- SourceLand Registry
Connectivity
Area Profile
Schools Nearby
- -International Christian Language School for Functional English0.1 mi
- Whitby School0.2 miRequires improvementConcerns
- West Cliff Primary School0.3 miGood
- Stakesby Primary Academy0.4 miGood
1 of 13 nearby schools with published figures were oversubscribed in 2026 - demand, not a catchment.
Comparables
- 13 Carrs Yard-£160k-
- 8 Carrs Yard-£192k-
- The Rockpool, 10 Carrs Yard-£185k-
- 2 Carrs Yard-£230k-