Old Garth House, Church Lane, Nunburnholme, York, YO42 1QU

UPRN:200000636857Detached House3 bedsBuilt before 1900

FreeholdCouncil Tax: -EPC: D (60)

Data freshness:Price Paid· freshPlanning· 4mo agoEPC· 3mo agoRisk· 5mo agoConnectivity· 1mo agoSchools· 1mo agoAmenities· 1mo agoArea· Census 2021

Old Garth House, Church Lane, Nunburnholme, York, YO42 1QU

HP Score

/ 100

Mixed

Verdict

today

Verdict: INVESTIGATE, on a scale of Buy, Investigate, Avoid.
Mixed signals - investigate

Evidence

16 of 21 sources

Sale Estimate

£500,000

£475k - £525kHigh

Estimate

£500k

Range

£475k – £525k

Rent Estimate (pcm)

£1,650

£1k - £2k

Monthly

£1,650

Yield

3.96%

Verdict

Derived from HomePortfolio scores

Old Garth House earns an INVESTIGATE rating with HP Score 58/100. Investment score 51/100 reflects moderate fundamentals. Crime intensity is very low. Walkability is limited (0/100). Flood risk is not assessed: check the Environment Agency long-term flood map before offering. Tenure is freehold. Every figure here comes from the live HomePortfolio API; anything it does not publish is left out.

Key SourcesEPC RegisterPortal listingsOfcom Connected NationsMarket estimates (third-party AVM)HM Land Registry sales matched to addressDefra strategic noise mapping, England Round 4 (Contains Defra data © Crown copyright and database right 2023-2024, Open Government Licence v3.0)Walk ScoreONS Census 2021Police.ukHM Land Registry covenantsHM Land Registry Price PaidPlanIt / council planning portalsOverture Maps PlacesOfsted / DfE GIAS

HP Score

58/ 100

Mixed

Investment Score

51/ 100

Moderate

Crime Score

5/ 100

Low

Walkability

0/ 100

Low

Transit & Bike

Transit 2Bike 19

Walk Score, out of 100

Opportunity

Why this could be an opportunity

Low confidence0 independent sourcesListing checked 30 Oct 2026

This rests largely on a single source. Treat the score as a prompt to investigate, not a conclusion.

Valuation edge0/15
claims [AVM +0.0% (HIGH)] → measured edge +0.00pp of the ask; on later-registered sales an AVM discount carried no edge and a sold-evidence gap at most +0.5pp
Market estimate used (HIGH confidence) · snapshot 9 Oct 2026
- valuation_snapshotsestimate for 200000636857· as of 9 Oct 2026
Rental economics0/40
gross yield 4.0%; range width penalty ×0.72
- valuation_snapshotsrent estimate 1650/mo (range 1450-1850)· as of 9 Oct 2026· verify before relying on this
Stress margin0/30
stressed cash flow -1,027/mo, -62% of rent (6.75% on a 75% loan; no service charge or ground rent disclosed); fails the stress - earns nothing
- underwriting_assumptionscosts not disclosed by the advert· as of 30 Oct 2026
Seller motivationNot scored
context, not scored: 1 price cut(s), 177 days on market; homes with a cut sold 0.2-0.3pp further below the cut ask, which is not an edge
- portal_listingsprice_changes + first_published_date· as of 30 Oct 2026
Risk & liquidity14.6/15
207 sales/12mo in area; valuation range width 10%
- property_intelligencetransactions_12mo

4 of 4 components scored. Ranks on gross yield, the stress margin, risk and disclosed facts. A pricing claim earns only its measured edge: today 0 for the market estimate and at most +0.5pp for sold evidence. The score itself is not yet checked against the outcomes of homes it scored.

Economics

What happens to your money

Price sensitivity

£375,000£575,000

The same scorer re-run at hypothetical asking prices, holding rent, comps and listing history constant. Not a prediction of what the seller would accept.

Your assumptions

Purchase price£500,000

At the asking price

Monthly rent£1,650/mo

Evidenced range £1,450-£1,850

Interest rate5.4%

Loan to value75%

Cash required: £166,300
Net cash flow: -£545/mo
Cash on cash: -3.9%
Score at this price: 15

After a 8% void allowance, 15% management and 10% maintenance. Lender coverage (rent ÷ interest): 0.98 - below the usual 1.25 test. These are your assumptions, not evidence: only the pre-filled rent and price come from the record.

Evidence

Where every number comes from

valuation_snapshotsestimate for 200000636857Valuation edge · as of 9 Oct 2026
valuation_snapshotsrent estimate 1650/mo (range 1450-1850)Rental economics · as of 9 Oct 2026 · verify before relying on this
underwriting_assumptionscosts not disclosed by the advertStress margin · as of 30 Oct 2026
portal_listingsprice_changes + first_published_dateSeller motivation · as of 30 Oct 2026
property_intelligencetransactions_12moRisk & liquidity

Sold comparables in depth

Risks

What could kill this deal

Score confidence is low
largely a single source - treat the number as a prompt, not a conclusion
Rental economics needs verification before you rely on it
rent estimate 1650/mo (range 1450-1850)
Seller motivation could not be scored
context, not scored: 1 price cut(s), 177 days on market; homes with a cut sold 0.2-0.3pp further below the cut ask, which is not an edge

Property risk deep-dive →

Plan

Before you offer

1. Get two written rental appraisals from local lettings agents.
The rent estimate rests on area-level evidence, not lettings on this street.
2. Ask the agent why the price was reduced and whether a previous sale fell through.
1 price cut(s) recorded on the listing history.
3. Treat the gap to the estimate as unproven - compare recent sold prices on the street yourself before pricing an offer around it.
On later completions, homes listed below their estimate sold at the same share of the asking price as the rest.
4. Commission a full structural survey, not a basic condition report.
The score prices market evidence, not the fabric of the building.

Valuation & Market

Sale Estimate£500,000

Rent Estimate (pcm)£1,650

Gross Yield3.96%

1y Growth-

3y Growth-2.2%

5y Growth+1.2%

10y Growth+2.6%

Last Sold Price£295,000 (2015-12-18)

View Market Details

Risk Overview

Flood RiskUnknown
SubsidenceModerate
RadonLow
MiningUnknown
LandslideLow
Air QualityLow
NoiseLow

View Full Risk Report

Planning Activity

Recent Apps

0YO42 1QU

Approval Rate

-12mo

Development

low

25/01246/PLF
Erection of single storey extension to rear following demolition of existing conservatory and outhouses, construction of dormer to rear
Approved
24/01466/PLF
Construction of a vehicular access (dropped kerb)
Approved
23/02850/AGNOT
Erection of an agricultural building and feed silo
Approved

View Planning Timeline

Ownership

Corporate Ownership79.5%
Overseas OwnershipNo
Lease Term Remaining-
CovenantsRestrictive
Lease TypeFreehold
Last Ownership Change2015-12-18
SourceLand Registry

View Ownership Details

Connectivity

Broadband (Standard)

11 Mbps

Mobile 4G/5G Coverage

EV Charger

PTAL Rating

View Connectivity Map

Area Profile

Median EarningsLocal authority£31,881

Population Density12 /km²

Owner Occupied54%

Age Distribution

0-15 16%16-64 61%65+ 23%

View Area Profile

Schools Nearby

Warter Church of England Primary School
1.9 mi
Good
Woldgate School and Sixth Form College
2.3 mi
Inspected as Woldgate College (URN 118081) on 13 May 2015
Allerthorpe School
2.8 mi
Inspected by ISI
Pocklington Church of England Voluntary Controlled Infant School
2.8 mi
Area grades2025
Inspected after Ofsted withdrew the single overall grade.

5 of 10 nearby schools with published figures were oversubscribed in 2026 - demand, not a catchment.

View All Schools

Comparables

View All

Huckleberry House
-
£885k
-
Halkon
-
£186k
-
Bracken Cottage
-
£530k
-
4 Brunham Cottages
-
£180k
-

Boundary data not available for this property

No registered title polygon, building footprint, or street match for this property yet.

Why: No HMLR INSPIRE / OSM footprint / OS Open USRN match for this UPRN

Source: HM Land Registry INSPIRE / OpenStreetMap / OS Open USRN